Get free quote in-app

(400K+)

Our Insurance Partners

nationwide
travellers
mapfre
safeco
kemper
national-general
foremost
dairyland
pronto
bristolwest
hippo
assuranceameric
anchor
still-water
bridger
alinsco
commonwealth
suncoast
aspire

Everyone wants what is best for them, no arguments about that. That would include auto insurance companies also. When you start looking for car insurance, you will always look for the best car insurance companies available in the market. Nothing less than best is what you would prefer. But does your definition of best car insurance companies automatically translate to cheap car insurance companies?

Purchasing adequate coverage for your vehicle is essential, if not overwhelming because it involves selecting an insurance agent, determining coverage amounts, and complying with state requirements. Way.com's insurance analyst team surveyed hundreds of insurance brokers to help narrow down this year's best choices to help you find the best auto insurance firms for your needs. We took into account each company's car insurance rates, as well as average financial strength and customer service scores from a variety of reliable third-party sources and ground reports.

Best car insurance companies of 2022

When you are looking for cheap car insurance companies remember to not to equate to the best car insurance companies. That is completely wrong. Various auto insurance companies calculate your car insurance premium based on the factors entere or given by you. When you are looking for car insurance companies online you will be asked to enter details from your personal life. This procedure repeats even when you search for the term ‘car insurance companies near me’.

The experts at Way.com have sifted through the various reliable available data to finalize the top car insurance companies. These car insurance companies are not final and can be subjected to change as per the customer feedback, rates, and other factors.

When selecting the best car insurance company, each driver has their priorities to consider. Your vehicle model, the ages of the drivers on your policy, the availability of insurance discounts, customer satisfaction, and the financial strength of the car insurance company will be taken into consideration by the top car insurance companies. The following companies have been ranked based on their quoted premiums for 2022.

When finding the right auto insurance providers, you can consider more than just average annual premiums. Way.com analysts considered how these businesses compare customer loyalty and willingness to pay claims, but you should still understand your user experience requirements.

While finding the best car insurance provider might be your priority, you may discover that another company provides more of what you need, such as a car insurance rate specifically in your price range, even though it is ranked lower on the list.

Certain companies may have more local agents, while others may provide specialized coverage for items like your car or fuel form. In contrast, still, others may provide benefits tailored to your profession. Finally, the right insurer would most likely be the one that best meets all of your auto insurance needs, including premium price, crash coverage, underinsured motorist coverage, medical costs, personal injury compensation, and so on.

Find out why each of these auto insurance firms made our list and how they differ in their coverage choices in the sections below. We've customized this information for the average driver, including comparing car insurance quotes for each insurer that show how average credit and common incidents on your driving record will affect your rates.

See what you could save on auto insurance

Allstate

Allstate is a reputable insurer with 90 years of experience and high customer ratings as one of the nation's most prominent insurance writers. Even though Allstate has been in business for a long time, it continues to evolve by offering a mobile app that streamlines the customer experience by providing direct access to local agents and policy documents. Allstate provides a user-friendly mobile app with two main features: policy management and its Drivewise software.

Policyholders can use the app to access ID cards, get roadside assistance, upload pictures after a claim, and even keep track of their personal belongings to make claim filing easier. The Drivewise program in the Allstate app analyzes your driving patterns, provides driving insights, and allows you to earn cashback every six months for safe driving.

Safe driving incentives can be redeemed via Allstate's rewards scheme, making it a compelling choice for drivers trying to save money on their insurance as well as in their daily lives. Signing up for Drivewise, enabling your rewards account, and avoiding speeding and abrupt braking are all ways to gain points.

Amica

Amica has one of the highest overall customer satisfaction ratings for Way.com's best car insurance providers. For more than 20 years, Amica has had the highest customer satisfaction among auto insurers, providing peace of mind to those seeking a customer-centric business model. The advantage is that you can have a fantastic time without sacrificing the appeal of a low-cost premium. Amica rewards its customers by paying out dividends per year and, where possible, giving you money back.

Amica is one of the few companies that offers drivers the chance to get up to 20% of their annual premiums back in dividends. Dividend policies have the advantage of lowering your long-term insurance costs and providing flexible dividend payout options, which usually range from 5% to 20% of your annual premium. Amica policyholders may also use their dividends to pay for future years' premiums.

Erie

Erie is available in 12 states and offers outstanding customer service and those insured by Erie to budget ahead of time. Drivers in the company's protected states can expect low prices and a Rate Lock feature, which helps keep your premiums from rising over time as long as your coverage remains the same. Erie insurance is only valid in 12 states and the District of Columbia.

If you make a claim, regardless of age, Erie's Rate Lock feature will help you keep your current rate as long as no other adjustments are made to your policy — a significant financial advantage. Erie also provides a particular auto insurance package called Erie Auto Plus for an extra eight cents a day (roughly $30 annually), which includes a decreasing premium and a $10,000 death benefit, among other benefits.

Nationwide

Drivers can save money in various ways with Nationwide, including two usage-based services that can save them a lot of money. Nationwide provides a free annual consultation with an insurance agent for drivers who want to keep a close eye on their plans to ensure that their coverage choices are still appropriate for their ever-changing needs.

Among our best car insurance providers, Nationwide is an especially appealing choice. Accident forgiveness is an optional benefit, and Nationwide's SmartRide and SmartMiles programs allow for customized savings. The SmartRide service will save you up to 40% on your insurance if you drive safely, plus you'll get a 10% discount just for signing up. Similarly, the SmartMiles program keeps track of your driving distance and gives you adjustable premiums depending on how much you drive.

Nationwide also offers a free On Your Side Review, which lets policyholders make sure their coverages are still adequate for their needs.

Progressive

Progressive is a forerunner in fostering creativity in the car insurance industry. Progressive provides a price-planning platform for coverage and a mobile app for usable ID cards, bill payment, and claim submission as it continues to digitize the insurance experience.

When drivers sign up for an auto insurance policy with Progressive, they can save up to $750 on average. The company also provides various discounts, including those exclusive, such as its Snapshot service, which helps you save an average of $145 per year by driving safely and driving fewer miles. Progressive also added Snapshot Road Test, which allows drivers who another insurer already insures to see how much money they can save if they switched to Progressive, making it one of the best auto insurance providers for visualizing savings before switching.

State Farm

State Farm is an excellent choice for those who want to know their insurance agent and get in-person insurance advice. With over agents on the ground around the country, you can be assured that you'll be able to discuss your insurance needs with a friendly local agent who knows the area well. State Farm continues to hold the largest share of the private passenger car insurance industry.

Although policyholders who prefer in-person experiences can take greater comfort in knowing that State Farm has close to 25000 agents around the country, a mobile app enables them to manage their policies, bills and directly communicate with agents.

State Farm offers discounts for safe driving or being accident-free. Many customers would be happy to learn that the company's overall premiums remain lower after an accident. This makes State Farm one of the top car insurance companies in the country.

The Hartford

For older drivers who choose to consider extra membership benefits, The Hartford is a top all-around insurer. Its association with the AARP Auto Insurance Program provides additional benefits such as house washing if you are involved in an accident covered by your policy. Customer loyalty, financial strength, mobile app scores, and a digitally-optimized business are positive points.

USAA

Few insurance companies provide military and veteran-related benefits or discounts, but USAA tailors its plans to meet the specific needs of these individuals. USAA has the highest customer satisfaction scores among its loyal customer base in every region of the country, indicating that the majority of policyholders vouch for its dependable customer support and claims processing.

USAA writes auto insurance plans for military personnel, veterans, and their qualifying family members around the country, including in Alaska and Hawaii, which have the most significant number of military service members. Members who use the company's new SafePilot software to monitor safe driving can see their winnings when the policy period ends and will be eligible to apply it during renewal. As part of USAA's core focus, its rules will cover you when you're deployed, and you can even get discounts for parking your car at a military base. Your family may be eligible for benefits as well.

While auto insurance losses are not always predictable, knowing that your insurer is financially stable will give you peace of mind. Several financial strength rating scales offer USAA high marks. For those who apply for eligibility, USAA is a top provider to consider for its reliability and more.

See what you could save on auto insurance

Basic points to remember when looking for best car insurance companies

Liability insurance, also known as minimum coverage auto insurance, is likely to have set minimum standards depending on the state you live in. Medical costs for bodily harm incurred to others, personal injury insurance (PIP) for you and your passengers, property damage liability (PDL), and uninsured motorist benefits are typically limited under minimum coverage.

If you are financing or leasing a car, however, you would generally be expected to insure it with an accident and comprehensive coverage, also known as "complete" coverage, in addition to your minimum liability. This protects both you and the lender from financial liability in the event of a vehicle failure or injury, such as in the event of a car accident.

The best insurer for your financed vehicle would most likely be one that provides the coverage you want at a reasonable price. Still, you can also look for ones that provide extra benefits like original equipment coverage, gap insurance, and even accident forgiveness.

Since each driver's situations are special, deciding the types and quantities of auto insurance coverage you need is a procedure that must be done individually.

Your budget, the age of your car, your financial health, and your risk tolerance all affect the coverage decision you make. If you're unsure what you need in car insurance, speaking with an insurance agent could be beneficial.

Auto Insurance Data Methodology

The auto insurance rates published in this guide are based on the results of research completed by Way.com’s data team. Using a mix of public and internal data, we analyzed millions of rate averages across U.S. ZIP codes.

Quotes are typically based on a full coverage policy average unless otherwise noted within the content.

These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes will differ. Given this, it’s important to go through our insurance steps form to find how much you can save with way.com

FAQ's

What is the best car insurance company?

The best car insurance companies put their customers first from quote to claim, providing a simple way to handle plans and pay bills. We at Way.com determined the following companies as the best cheap car insurance companies in the US: Amica, Allstate, American Family and Farmers.

Can insurance companies force you to total your car?

Auto insurance companies can total your car. The best car insurance companies will determine the pre-accident value of your car after an accident.

When does an insurance company total a car?

When the cost of restoring the vehicle to its pre-damaged state exceeds the present value of the car, the insurance firm declares the car a "complete loss" and determines the car's ‘Actual Cash Value.’

How do insurance companies value cars?

The top car insurance companies use industry formulas to measure your car's actual cash value. It isn't easy to guess how they'll decide your vehicle's pre-collision value. However, if you believe the insurer undervalued your car after it was totaled and you are owing more than they are offering, you might be able to challenge the ACV they calculated.

What car insurance companies cover salvage titles?

After an accident and a total loss insurance claim, a salvage title is rebranded. The following car insurance companies cover salvage titles: 21st Century, Esurance, Everest, General Insurance, Infinity, Insurance, National General, Omni, Progressive, Safeco, The Hartford, and Titan.

How to switch car insurance companies?

If you are planning to switch car insurance companies, you can follow the following steps:

Why should I compare auto policy quotes between the best insurance companies?

Shopping around and taking the time to compare auto policy quotes from the best insurance companies will make sure your wallet stays healthy while getting more than adequate car insurance coverage for your vehicle. We recommend revisiting your policy options once a year - remember to check online for any updates or add-ons to your existing policy as well.

How do I find the best car insurance online?

Getting your car insurance quotes online is the easiest and quickest way to get the best car insurance rates. This can also help you get the most value for money coverage for the best car insurance rates. Comparing auto insurance quotes on Way.com saves you time, money, and worry. On Way.com, you can get free car insurance quotes in less than a minute, compare the best cheap car insurance quotes carefully, and then choose to buy online or via our insurance agents.

Should I compare rates among the best insurance companies when moving states?

The state you live in has a huge impact on the kind of rates you shell out for insurance coverage. If you find yourself moving between states, ensuring you compare car insurance rates from the best insurance companies online makes for efficient financial planning.

Which insurance is best for car gap insurance?

Some of the best car insurance rates for gap insurance are offered by Allstate Insurance, Amica Insurance, Nationwide Insurance, American Family Insurance. You can scroll down for more details.

Learn more by city and state for car insurance



Learn more by city and state for car insurance




Digital Insurance Card

Access your digital insurance card through the app. You no longer need to carry your physical insurance card with you.

Get reminders & quotes

Receive reminders before your renewal. Way.com will also send new quotes from up to 45 insurance companies with your renewal reminder.

Share with family

Keep everyone on your policy up to date by sharing your insurance information.

Manage your policy

Make changes to your policy right from the app (coming soon) and ask for expert advice.

Get the App:

Find the best Auto insurance rates on-the-go

For the best user experience, please download our Way app.

Please Enter A Valid Mobile Number!
Text Sent, Please download!

or