Get 5% off in-app
400k+ download
Open app

Best car insurances for 2021

  • Cars Explained
  • Xavier Sabastian
  • 8 minutes

Spread the love

The¬†best car insurance companies¬†in the¬†United States¬†vary depending on the driver, the vehicle, and the location. Auto insurance companies like Progressive, Allstate, and¬†Amica Mutual are three of the world’s best-rated auto insurance companies.¬†


When choosing an insurance provider, cheap car insurance rates are not the only factor you need to consider. The best auto insurance companies will provide you with affordable coverage, have excellent customer reviews, and are financially strong. Auto insurance is required by law in 49 states. As a consumer, you have the right to purchase coverage that is both reliable and affordable from a company that you know you can trust.  

Below, we’ve gathered all the research for you in one convenient location. Together we will examine the rates, financial stability, and reputation of the nation’s leading auto insurance providers to determine which company is right for you.¬†

Which insurance companies have the best rates for a car?

An estimated annual cost of car accidents in the United States is calculated at $242 billion. Here are some of the relevant auto insurance statistics provided by the National Highway Safety Administration:  

Average vehicle liability claims for property damages: $3231  

Average liability claims for bodily injury: $15443  

Average collision claims: $3144  

Average comprehensive claims: $3144  


There are many different types and sizes of car insurance companies, so choosing who will have your back can be nerve-wracking.  

Can you believe that only ten car insurance companies dominate 72% of the national private passenger car insurance market? Even more incredible is that only four of those ten car insurance companies share 51% of the same market.  

We’re not here to tell you which company to choose, but we’re here to explain every aspect so that it will be easier for you to make your decision. A cheap car insurance policy is not always the best policy. However, car insurance rates are key factors that consumers consider when choosing an insurance provider.¬†¬†

Let’s start by comparing the average annual rates of the top 10 car insurance providers in the United States and discuss their availability across the nation. The table below includes each of the top 10 companies, their average annual premium on a national scale compared to the national average, and their cheapest insured vehicle.¬†

Company  Availability  Average Annual Rates 
Allstate  All over the country   $4532.96 
American Family  19 States  $3698.77 
Farmers  All over the country  $3907.99 
Liberty Mutual  All over the country  $5295.55 
Nationwide  46 States  $3187.20 
Progressive  All over the country  $3935.36 
State Farm  All over the country  $2731.48 
Travelers  42 States  $3729.32 

(Military & Family Members) 

All over the country  $2489.49 


Top car insurance with the lowest rates

Some of the top-rated insurance firms could have the lowest rates. Below you’ll find the top 10 car insurance firms in the USA:¬†¬†

  • State Farm¬†
  • Progressive¬†
  • Allstate¬†
  • USAA¬†
  • Liberty Mutual¬†
  • Farmers Insurance¬†
  • Nationwide¬†
  • Travelers¬†
  • American Family


Judging a business with rates and financial stability is a great start, but what about customer service? It is essential to analyze both new and recurrent customer satisfaction ratings when selecting¬†or changing auto insurance providers. You can also take a look at the company’s claims filing process. Getting in a car accident is traumatic enough. You don’t want to find that your provider’s claims process is slow, confusing, and frustrating when it’s too late.¬†

Things to know before you opt for car insurance

Choosing the right car insurance company can be a long and complicated operation. The first step in finding the right insurance agent is not just to find your cheapest quote. The comparison of¬†quotes should be your final step. Don’t assume that you’re going to get the same coverage and rates from each provider. You are likely to obtain very different rates. No two companies use the same calculation when measuring rates or offering the same coverage choices.¬†

Study the types of coverage

A great way to start your search is by searching for details about the critical categories of coverage and assessing your budget. 


Lets look at this list of basic coverages you may need: 

Bodily Injury Liability (BI)¬†‚Äď This Coverage accounts for the bodily harm of other drivers and passengers (if any) when you are at fault in an accident.¬†¬†

Property Damage Liability (PD)¬†‚Äď This coverage accounts for the cost of property damage that you sustained in the event of an accident.¬†

Collision Coverage¬†‚Äď This coverage accounts for the damages of your vehicle, regardless of who was at fault.¬†

Comprehensive Coverage¬†‚Äď This plan covers damage to your car that does not include a crash, such as vandalism, theft, fire, floods, etc.¬†¬†

Underinsured Motorist Coverage (UIM)¬†‚ÄstThis coverage offers protection if the default driver does not have adequate coverage to compensate for property harm or bodily injury.¬†¬†

Uninsured Motorist Coverage (UM)¬†‚ÄstThis insurance policy will reimburse bodily injuries if you have been struck by a hit-and-run driver or have been involved in a collision with a driver who has no car insurance.¬†¬†

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)¬†‚Äď This coverage accounts for physical harm and loss of income, regardless of who is at fault.¬†¬†

Medical Payments (MedPay) ‚Äď This is an additional compensation choice to help you with medical expenses that are not protected by PIP or liability.¬†

What factors impact your car insurance rates?

Factors like where you live, the laws in your state, and various other factors impact your car insurance rates. These factors include but are not limited to your age, driving record, ZIP code, credit history, the type of vehicle you drive, and how much you drive.  

Car insurance cancellations have a penalty

If you’re tired of paying high premiums and need a more attractive insurance option from our guide, make sure to review the fine print on your current policy before you cancel mid-term.¬†¬†Midterm cancellations are permitted, and you can buy a new car insurance policy at any time. However, it is essential to consult with your insurance provider and your state laws to decide if you will have to pay any cancellation fees. To entirely avoid cancellation fees, please transfer providers when your policy is up for renewal.¬†¬†

The financial health of automobile insurance firms

The financial health of the insurer is another facet that customers can consider when selecting an insurance policy. Your insurer should be able to make a claim even in the case of an economic downturn.¬† Its historic financial stability measures the insurance provider’s future economic strength, especially its top competitors. Third-party companies, such as A.M. Best, use¬†an intricate algorithm to score and forecast financial stability.¬†¬†

 Three statistics that customers like yourself can use to assess the financial health of a business are as follows:  

 Direct Premiums Written: the actual dollar sum of premiums paid by the insurance provider without any change.  

Market Share: shows the percentage of the market concentration in the line of business that the company controls.  

Damage Ratio: a proportion that reflects the amount paid in favor of the claims against which the firm receives premiums. 

How to Choose Between Big and Small Car Insurance Companies

We’re looking at the top companies in this report, but they are all big national businesses. Local providers can often be the best option for your auto insurance policy. To help you choose without feeling frustrated, we’ve put together a list of critical considerations and questions to consider before you even search for a quote to lighten your load.¬†¬†

  • Do I want to do business with an agent, through a broker, directly with a supplier, online-only, via a national company, or through a local company?¬†¬†
  • What is¬†each company’s financial health, and what are their positions for the future when it comes to market share, loss ratios, and third-party rankings?¬†¬†
  • What company provides the best coverage and the best discounts and prices for my specific features and needs?¬†¬†
  • How happy are each company’s customers with the services and claims process?¬†¬†
  • How many and what types of consumer complaints have been made against each company?¬†¬†

To help you decide whether you want to use a small car insurance company or one of the larger firms, ask yourself what your primary concern is about the company you are insured with. You may be more interested in customer service than at low prices. A small business may have been right for you.  

Do small car insurance firms offer the best rates? 

It’s not always. However, customer experience is often much more personal and family-like through a small company than through significant providers. Or maybe you want to have many policy choices, even though that means sacrificing good customer service. Larger businesses are typically able to offer a variety of discounts and more exclusive additional policies.¬†¬†


Often, independent auto insurance firms operate under the oversight of the major insurers.¬†So¬†check to see if the local department you’re looking at is part of¬†a larger community. Besides, big insurance providers have an easier time diversifying their offerings to all vehicle owners. On the other hand, local departments would target more individual drivers, such as those who own antique or collectible cars. As you can see, deciding if big auto insurance providers are better than smaller ones¬†depends¬†on various variables and preferences.¬†¬†

At the end of the day, choose the business that’s right for you.¬†

what happens if you get caught driving without insurance

Related Posts


Press ESC to close