Bay Shore Average Gas Price
| Regular | Mid-Grade | Premium | Diesel | E85 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Month Ago Avg. | $3.68 | $4.11 | $4.53 | $5.04 | $2.55 |
Highest Recorded Average Gas Price In Bay Shore Year to Date
| Price | Date | |
|---|---|---|
| Diesel | $5.04 | 09/21/26 |
| Regular | $3.68 | 10/11/26 |
Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in Bay Shore
Exxon in Bay Shore (172 Howells Rd)
172 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, New York,
$3.79
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
76 in Bay Shore (989 Sunrise Hwy)
989 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, New York,
$3.79
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Mobil in Bay Shore (236 Bay Shore Rd)
236 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.23
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Mobil in Bay Shore (211 5th Ave)
211 5th Ave, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.29
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Mobil in Bay Shore (1050 Udall Rd)
1050 Udall Rd, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.39
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Speedway in Bay Shore (327 E Main St)
327 E Main St, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.54
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
7-Eleven in Bay Shore (2320 Union Blvd)
2320 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.59
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Mobil in Bay Shore (221 W Main St)
221 W Main St, Bay Shore, New York,
$4.69
Oct 24, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Find Cheap Gas Prices By State
Click on the state to view the State details
Gas Data Methodology
The fuel prices published in this guide are based on the results of research completed by Way.com’s data team. Using a mix of external and internal data, we analyzed millions of prices across U.S. ZIP codes and globally.