There are no items available in your cart

Close

New Castle Average Gas Price

RegularMid-GradePremiumDieselE85
Month Ago Avg. $4.44 $4.81 $5.19 $5.61 $4.07

Highest Recorded Average Gas Price In New Castle Year to Date

PriceDate
Diesel$5.6209/13/26
Regular$4.4509/15/26

Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in New Castle

Sunoco in New Castle (2895 New Butler Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

2895 NEW BUTLER RD, NEW CASTLE, Pennsylvania,

$3.50

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

Sunoco in New Castle (2895 New Butler Rd)
2895 NEW BUTLER RDNEW CASTLEPennsylvania16101US

GetGo in New Castle (1901 W State St)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

1901 W State St, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.79

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

GetGo in New Castle (1901 W State St)
1901 W State StNew CastlePennsylvania16101USA

Sheetz in New Castle (3405 Wilmington Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

3405 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.79

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

Sheetz in New Castle (3405 Wilmington Rd)
3405 Wilmington RdNew CastlePennsylvania16105USA

GetGo in New Castle (3224 Wilmington Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

3224 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.79

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

GetGo in New Castle (3224 Wilmington Rd)
3224 Wilmington RdNew CastlePennsylvania16105USA

BP in New Castle (1001 Mt. Jackson Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

1001 MOUNT JACKSON RD, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.79

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

BP in New Castle (1001 Mt. Jackson Rd)
1001 MOUNT JACKSON RDNew CastlePennsylvania16102USA

Marathon in New Castle (1509 Wilmington Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

1509 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.93

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

Marathon in New Castle (1509 Wilmington Rd)
1509 Wilmington RdNew CastlePennsylvania16105USA

GetGo in New Castle (1700-B New Butler Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

1700-B New Butler Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.94

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

GetGo in New Castle (1700-B New Butler Rd)
1700-B New Butler RdNew CastlePennsylvania16101USA

CITGO in New Castle (513 Montgomery Ave)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

513 Montgomery Ave, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.99

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

CITGO in New Castle (513 Montgomery Ave)
513 Montgomery AveNew CastlePennsylvania16102USA

Marathon in New Castle (2505 Ellwood Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

2505 Ellwood Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.99

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

Marathon in New Castle (2505 Ellwood Rd)
2505 Ellwood RdNew CastlePennsylvania16101USA

Sheetz in New Castle (3208 New Butler Rd)

( )★( )★( )★( )★( )★()

3208 New Butler Rd, New Castle, Pennsylvania,

$4.99

Oct 25, 2026

0¢ Cashback

Sheetz in New Castle (3208 New Butler Rd)
3208 New Butler RdNew CastlePennsylvania16101USA

Gas Data Methodology

The fuel prices published in this guide are based on the results of research completed by Way.com’s data team. Using a mix of external and internal data, we analyzed millions of prices across U.S. ZIP codes and globally.

Completing your PayPal payment…

Securely returning you to checkout. This will only take a moment.

Completing your Venmo payment…

Securely returning you to checkout. This will only take a moment.