Butler Average Gas Price
| Regular | Mid-Grade | Premium | Diesel | E85 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week Ago Avg. | $4.06 | $4.29 | $4.73 | $4.84 | $3.64 |
| Month Ago Avg. | $4.05 | $4.27 | $4.71 | $4.85 | $3.64 |
Highest Recorded Average Gas Price In Butler Year to Date
| Price | Date | |
|---|---|---|
| Diesel | $4.85 | 04/25/26 |
| Regular | $4.07 | 05/06/26 |
Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in Butler
Sunoco in Butler (520 E Jefferson St)
520 E Jefferson St, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.74
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
University Korner in Butler (1125 N Main St Ext)
1125 N Main St Ext, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.79
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sheetz in Butler (249 Pittsburgh Rd)
249 Pittsburgh Rd, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.89
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sheetz in Butler (499 Evans City Rd)
499 Evans City Rd, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.89
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sheetz in Butler (1100 Center Ave)
1100 Center Ave, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.89
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sheetz in Butler (1518 N Main St Ext)
1518 N Main St Ext, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.89
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sunoco in Butler (390 Whitestown Rd)
390 Whitestown Rd, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$3.92
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Sheetz in Butler (356 New Castle Rd)
356 New Castle Rd, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$5.29
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
GetGo in Butler (1024 N Main St)
1024 North Main Street, Butler, Pennsylvania,
$5.35
May 09, 2026
0¢ Cashback
Find Cheap Gas Prices By State
Click on the state to view the State details
Gas Data Methodology
The fuel prices published in this guide are based on the results of research completed by Way.com’s data team. Using a mix of external and internal data, we analyzed millions of prices across U.S. ZIP codes and globally.