We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience, personalize content, and analyze website traffic. For these reasons, we may share your site usage data with our analytics partners. By clicking “Accept,” you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy. You can change your cookie settings at any time by clicking “Preferences.”

Gas

There are no items available in your cart

Close

37+ Gas stations in Middle island, NY

Hide Map
Shell in Middle Island (809 Middle Country Rd)
3¢/gal Discount
Nearest

Shell in Middle Island (809 Middle Country Rd)

Regular, Diesel

0.0 mi away
Starts at
$3.95 $3.92/gal
Shell in Middle Island (809 Middle Country Rd)
809 Middle Country RdMiddle IslandNew York11953USA
7-Eleven in Middle Island (813 Middle Country Rd)
Nearest

7-Eleven in Middle Island (813 Middle Country Rd)

Mid-grade, Diesel, Premium, Regular

0.0 mi away
Starts at
$4.35/gal
7-Eleven in Middle Island (813 Middle Country Rd)
813 Middle Country RdMiddle IslandNew York11953USA
Shell in Yaphank (482 Sills Rd)
3¢/gal Discount

Shell in Yaphank (482 Sills Rd)

Regular, Diesel

3.6 mi away
Starts at
$3.39 $3.36/gal
Shell in Yaphank (482 Sills Rd)
482 Sills RdYaphankNew York11980USA
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)
7¢/gal Cashback

BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

Regular, Mid-grade, Premium, Diesel

3.8 mi away
Starts at
$4.06 $3.99/gal
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)
3417 ROUTE 112MedfordNew York11763USA
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)
7¢/gal Cashback

BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

Regular, Mid-grade, Premium, Diesel

3.8 mi away
Starts at
$4.06 $3.99/gal
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)
3417 Rte 112MedfordNew York11763US
Shell in Miller Place (1025 NY-25A)
3¢/gal Discount

Shell in Miller Place (1025 NY-25A)

Regular, Mid-grade, Premium

4.4 mi away
Starts at
$3.99 $3.96/gal
Shell in Miller Place (1025 NY-25A)
1025 NY-25AMiller PlaceNew York11764USA
BP in Middle Island (975 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD)

BP in Middle Island (975 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD)

Regular

0.5 mi away
Starts at
$4.35/gal
BP in Middle Island (975 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD)
975 Middle Country RdMiddle IslandNew York11953USA
US Fuel in Middle Island (1146 Middle Country Rd)

US Fuel in Middle Island (1146 Middle Country Rd)

0.9 mi away
US Fuel in Middle Island (1146 Middle Country Rd)
1146 Middle Country RdMiddle IslandNew York11953USA
Mobil in Ridge (1823 Middle Country Rd)

Mobil in Ridge (1823 Middle Country Rd)

Regular, Mid-grade, Premium, Diesel

2.1 mi away
Starts at
$3.89/gal
Mobil in Ridge (1823 Middle Country Rd)
1823 Middle Country RdRidgeNew York11961USA
Mobil in Coram (145 Middle Country Rd)

Mobil in Coram (145 Middle Country Rd)

Regular, Diesel, Premium

2.5 mi away
Starts at
$3.09/gal
Mobil in Coram (145 Middle Country Rd)
145 Middle Country RdCoramNew York11727USA
Sunoco in Ridge (1511 Middle Country Rd)

Sunoco in Ridge (1511 Middle Country Rd)

Regular, Mid-grade, Premium

2.7 mi away
Starts at
$3.95/gal
Sunoco in Ridge (1511 Middle Country Rd)
1511 Middle Country RdRidgeNew York11961USA
BP in Yaphank (449 MAIN ST)

BP in Yaphank (449 MAIN ST)

2.9 mi away
BP in Yaphank (449 MAIN ST)
449 Main StYaphankNew York11980USA
Middle island, NY
$3.92
3¢/gal Off
Shell in Middle Island (809 Middle Country Rd)

Shell in Middle Island (809 Middle Country Rd)

0.0 mi away --
Starts at
$3.95 $3.92/gal
$4.35
7-Eleven in Middle Island (813 Middle Country Rd)

7-Eleven in Middle Island (813 Middle Country Rd)

0.0 mi away --
Starts at
$4.35/gal
$3.36
3¢/gal Off
Shell in Yaphank (482 Sills Rd)

Shell in Yaphank (482 Sills Rd)

3.6 mi away --
Starts at
$3.39 $3.36/gal
$3.99
7¢/gal back
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

3.8 mi away --
Starts at
$4.06 $3.99/gal
$3.99
7¢/gal back
BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

BP in Medford (3417 Rte 112)

3.8 mi away --
Starts at
$4.06 $3.99/gal
$3.96
3¢/gal Off
Shell in Miller Place (1025 NY-25A)

Shell in Miller Place (1025 NY-25A)

4.4 mi away --
Starts at
$3.99 $3.96/gal
$4.35
BP in Middle Island (975 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD)

BP in Middle Island (975 MIDDLE COUNTRY RD)

0.5 mi away --
Starts at
$4.35/gal
$-.--
US Fuel in Middle Island (1146 Middle Country Rd)

US Fuel in Middle Island (1146 Middle Country Rd)

0.9 mi away --
$3.89
Mobil in Ridge (1823 Middle Country Rd)

Mobil in Ridge (1823 Middle Country Rd)

2.1 mi away --
Starts at
$3.89/gal
$3.09
Mobil in Coram (145 Middle Country Rd)

Mobil in Coram (145 Middle Country Rd)

2.5 mi away --
Starts at
$3.09/gal
$3.95
Sunoco in Ridge (1511 Middle Country Rd)

Sunoco in Ridge (1511 Middle Country Rd)

2.7 mi away --
Starts at
$3.95/gal
$-.--
BP in Yaphank (449 MAIN ST)

BP in Yaphank (449 MAIN ST)

2.9 mi away --
12 Gas stations near Middle island, NY

Gas stations near Middle island, NY

Find top gas stations in or near Middle island, NY. Get cashback up to 25¢ per gallon, using the Way app at your local gas station.

How to Guides

Frequently asked questions

What are gas prices in Middle island, NY?
What are the three types of gas at the pump?
Can a gas car run diesel?

Completing your PayPal payment…

Securely returning you to checkout. This will only take a moment.

Completing your Venmo payment…

Securely returning you to checkout. This will only take a moment.