Slide 1 of 1 
- Fuel Types
- How To
- Amenities
- Reviews
Atlantis Fresh Market in Bethpage (486 N WANTAGH AVE)
486 N WANTAGH AVE, Bethpage, New York, 11714 |
- Fuel Types
- How To
- Amenities
- Reviews
Fuel Types
| Regular | Mid-grade | Premium | Diesel |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2.98/Gallon | $3.53/Gallon | $3.89/Gallon | $3.69/Gallon |
How to Get Gas Cashback
1. Download the Way app & search for gas stations near you.
2. Claim the offer & enter card details
3. Fuel up & enjoy your cashback!
Operating Hours
Sun : 24 hoursMon : 24 hoursTue : 24 hoursWed : 24 hoursThu : 24 hoursFri : 24 hoursSat : 24 hoursAmenities
Restrooms
C-Store
Propane
Air Pump
Beer
Loyalty Discount
Membership Pricing
Pay At Pump
ATM
Lotto
Restaurant
Wine
Reviews
WAY GUEST USER
04, Feb, 2026
Atlantis gas station in Bethpage is always my go to for the lowest gas price around. Great selection of tasty food, desserts, hot & iced coffee, soda & candy. Great to pick up snacks & drinks before we go to the movies.
Similar Listings
BP in Hicksville (324 Jerusalem Ave)
$3.46/Gal
-- (0)•1.8 miles324 Jerusalem Avenue, Hicksville, New York, US, 11802
Sunoco in Levittown (606 Wantagh Ave)
$3.39/Gal-- (0)•2.0 miles606 Wantagh Ave, Levittown, New York, USA, 11756
BP in Hicksville (106 N Broadway)
$3.55/Gal-- (0)•2.9 miles106 N BROADWAY, Hicksville, New York, USA, 11801
BP in Hicksville (300 N Broadway)
$3.50/Gal-- (0)•3.4 miles300 N Broadway, Hicksville, New York, USA, 11801
Atlantis Fresh Market in Bethpage (486 N WANTAGH AVE)486 N WANTAGH AVE, Bethpage, New York, 11714https://www.way.com/way-consumer/v1/public/images/listing_image/Listing_GasDefault27_imghttps://www.way.com/way-consumer/v1/public/images/listing_image/Listing_GasDefault27_img
2 stars - based on 528 reviews