Get free quote in-app

(400K+)

Best New Mexico Home Insurance (August 23)

Protect Your Home with Homeowners Insurance and Save with Way

√ Free quotes from 150+ carriers in seconds

√ Lowest rate guaranteed

√ No Spam or Long Forms



consumerreports
Lifehacker

Are you looking to get the best home insurance in New Mexico? We have analyzed all the major insurance companies to guide you in finding the best homeowners insurance in New Mexico.

Key Takeaways

  • New Mexico homeowners insurance costs $1,716 annually.
  • Insurers offer home insurance policies in the state starting at around $996 annually.
  • Wildfires often happen in the state. So ensure to have adequate coverage to cover fire damage.

New Mexico homeowners insurance: What you need to know

The average cost of homeowners insurance in New Mexico comes to around $1,716 yearly. It is almost on par with the national average rate.

Homeowners in New Mexico should be aware of the weather risks that can affect the state. Although severe weather events are uncommon, when they do occur, they can cause extensive damage to homes. So it is best to have a strong home insurance policy with ample coverage and discounts. Don’t worry.

We will help you find the best homeowners insurance in New Mexico!

What does a homeowners insurance policy cover?

Dwelling, Medical Payments to Others, Liability, Personal Property, Other Structures, and Additional Living Expenses are typical coverages a home insurance policy offers. But also, you can buy these coverages in the state.

  • Flood insurance: Flood damage isn't typically covered by a standard home insurance policy. Although some insurance companies provide flood insurance as an add-on, you must buy a separate one.
  • Sump pump coverage: It pays for the repair of clogged sump pumps and pipes. It will also offer coverage for any unintentional water damage caused by backups. A home insurance policy doesn't cover pump and water backup coverage. Still, many insurers offer it as optional coverage.
  • Yard and garden coverage: It will help pay for relandscaping your yard if a covered peril, like a fire, damages your trees, garden, lawn, or shrubs. Standard home insurance policies offer coverage for up to 5% of the dwelling amount (up to $500 per tree, bush, or shrub).

What isn’t covered by a typical homeowners insurance policy?

Home insurance doesn’t cover flooding, earthquakes, insect and vermin infestations, nuclear threats, power outages, war, wear and tear, sinkholes, or intentional loss. To ensure the coverages you get, you must carefully research your policy before purchasing one.

The cheapest home insurance companies in New Mexico

With an average yearly rate of $996, Liberty Mutual offers the most affordable home insurance in New Mexico. Do you want to buy a policy at an even cheaper rate? Then it is best to compare all the quotes from insurers and buy one.

Insurer Average annual rate
Liberty Mutual $996
Safeco $1,317
Allstate $1,374
USAA $1,496
State Farm $1,648

See what you could save on home insurance

The best homeowners insurance in New Mexico for those with poor credit

A low credit score can also increase your home insurance rates. Insurance companies assume homeowners with low credit scores are more likely to file claims for minor damages. So, they frequently increase rates on these customers to account for the increased risk. Farmers have the lowest insurance rates in New Mexico for a homeowner with poor credit, with an average yearly premium of $2,696.

Insurer Average annual rate
Farmers $2,696
State Farm $3,448

The best homeowners insurance in New Mexico for pool owners

Pool owners may face higher home insurance premiums as pools increase the possibility of a homeowner filing a liability claim. So insurers charge higher premiums to compensate. Farmers have the lowest home insurance rates for New Mexico homes with swimming pools, with an average annual premium of $1,646.

Insurer Average annual rate
Farmers $1,646
State Farm $2,015

The best homeowners insurance in New Mexico for dog owners

Insurers consider certain dog breeds ‘aggressive’ or ‘dangerous’ because they are likely to injure someone. So if you own one such a breed, you will most likely have to pay higher insurance rates. Farmers have the lowest home insurance rates in the state for a home with a dangerous dog breed, with an average yearly premium of $1,593.

Insurer Average annual rate
Farmers $1,593
State Farm $2,015

Homeowners insurance deductibles in New Mexico

When buying a home insurance policy, homeowners must decide how high or low to set their deductible. The deductible is the sum that you must pay towards a covered loss. The deductible you choose impacts the amount you pay for the coverage. So, the lower your deductible, the higher your premium. The following are some typical deductibles available in the state.

Deductible Level Average annual rate
$500 $1,678
$1,000 $1,577
$1,500 $1,513
$2,000 $1,389
$5,000 $1,239

New Mexico home insurance prices by coverage levels

The coverage level you choose impacts the insurance premiums you pay. In New Mexico, homeowners with $100,000 in dwelling coverage pay an average of $850 yearly, while those with $400,000 pay around $2,254 annually.

Dwelling coverage cost Average annual rate
$100,000 $850
$200,000 $1,253
$250,000 $1,577
$400,000 $2,254

New Mexico homeowners insurance costs by city

The New Mexico home insurance rates vary by the place you live. The ZIP Code, the area’s theft rate, and the volume of nearby claims can impact your premiums. These are the rates in various cities.

City Average annual rate
Abiquiu $912
Adelino $992
Agua Fria $783
Alamo $918
Alamogordo $879
Albuquerque $1,057
Alcalde $822
Algodones $849
Alto $982
Amalia $867
Amistad $4,440
Angel Fire $1,361
Animas $808
Anthony $769
Anton Chico $1,456
Aragon $919
Arenas Valley $795
Arrey $794
Arroyo Seco $902
Artesia $2,358
Atoka $2,362
Aztec $814
Bard $3,396
Bayard $768
Belen $1,000
Bent $881
Berino $872
Bernalillo $828
Black Rock $924
Blanco $828
Bloomfield $863
Bluewater Village $754
Bosque $933
Bosque Farms $890
Brimhall $954
Broadview $2,906
Buckhorn $828
Buena Vista $1,450
Caballo $830
Canjilon $877
Cannon AFB $2,801
Canones $877
Capitan $933
Caprock $2,300
Capulin $3,482
Carlsbad $2,302
Carnuel $828
Carrizozo $878
Carson $878
Casa Blanca $844
Causey $2,214
Cebolla $877
Cedar Crest $834
Cedar Grove $883
Cedarvale $964
Cedro $865
Cerrillos $823
Cerro $878
Chacon $986
Chama $886
Chamberino $778
Chamisal $888
Chamita $823
Chaparral $952
Chimayo $878
Church Rock $945
Cimarron $1,182
Claunch $814
Clayton $2,110
Cleveland $986
Cliff $5,357
Clines Corners $920
Cloudcroft $885
Clovis $2,828
Cochiti Lake $902
Cochiti Pueblo $959
Columbus $1,222
Conchas Dam $1,939
Continental Divide $832
Cordova $1,012
Corona $948
Corrales $779
Costilla $1,016
Counselor $849
Coyote $821
Crossroads $2,300
Crownpoint $797
Cuartelez $851
Cuba $862
Cubero $844
Cuervo $2,127
Datil $906
Deming $1,179
Derry $816
Des Moines $3,684
Dexter $1,880
Dixon $812
Dona Ana $5,369
Dulce $854
Eagle Nest $1,054
Edgewood $887
El Cerro $985
El Cerro Mission $989
El Prado $872
El Rancho $812
El Rito $831
Eldorado at Santa Fe $794
Elephant Butte $864
Elida $2,214
Embudo $816
Encino $1,097
Espanola $876
Estancia $996
Eunice $2,782
Fairacres $770
Farmington $768
Faywood $838
Fence Lake $874
Flora Vista $902
Floyd $2,807
Folsom $4,440
Fort Bayard $852
Fort Stanton $943
Fort Sumner $2,974
Fort Wingate $858
Fruitland $795
Gallina $871
Gallup $911
Gamerco $845
Garfield $788
Garita $2,162
Gila $833
Gladstone $3,684
Glencoe $983
Glenwood $857
Glorieta $811
Grady $2,906
Grants $748
Grenville $4,440
Guadalupita $1,093
Hachita $853
Hagerman $1,684
Hanover $815
Hatch $778
Hernandez $787
High Rolls Mountain Park $909
Hillsboro $860
Hobbs $2,728
Holloman AFB $913
Holman $1,147
Hondo $958
Hope $1,736
House $2,824
Hurley $782
Ilfeld $988
Isleta $776
Jal $2,765
Jamestown $986
Jarales $1,016
Jemez Pueblo $841
Jemez Springs $813
Kenna $5,795
Kirtland $829
Kirtland Air Force Base $5,415
La Cienega $774
La Huerta $2,311
La Jara $864
La Joya $951
La Loma $2,031
La Luz $1,093
La Madera $994
La Mesa $782
La Mesilla $890
La Plata $823
La Puebla $883
La Union $772
La Villita $827
Laguna $852
Lake Arthur $1,978
Lakewood $1,832
Lamy $896
Las Cruces $796
Las Maravillas $990
Las Vegas $1,469
Lee Acres $758
Lemitar $944
Lincoln $943
Lindrith $884
Lingo $2,214
Livingston Wheeler $2,308
Llano $892
Loco Hills $1,870
Logan $3,363
Lordsburg $955
Los Alamos $798
Los Chaves $991
Los Lunas $991
Los Ojos $820
Los Ranchos de Albuquerque $837
Loving $2,392
Lovington $2,717
Luna $854
Magdalena $892
Malaga $1,910
Maljamar $2,138
Maxwell $3,386
Mayhill $956
Mcalister $2,824
Mcdonald $2,138
McIntosh $975
Meadow Lake $984
Medanales $5,415
Melrose $3,528
Mentmore $875
Mescalero $957
Mesilla $768
Mesilla Park $814
Mesquite $794
Mexican Springs $860
Miami $1,067
Milan $753
Mills $2,692
Milnesand $2,415
Mimbres $837
Monterey Park $989
Montezuma $1,321
Monticello $838
Monument $2,195
Mora $1,115
Moriarty $940
Mosquero $3,230
Mountainair $963
Mule Creek $816
Nageezi $904
Nambe $823
Napi Headquarters $762
Nara Visa $2,953
Navajo $934
Navajo Dam $840
New Laguna $881
Newcomb $780
Newkirk $1,939
Nogal $993
North Hobbs $2,656
North Valley $829
Ocate $1,093
Ohkay Owingeh $821
Ojo Caliente $859
Ojo Feliz $1,093
Organ $858
Orogrande $5,479
Paguate $906
Paradise Hills $842
Pecos $1,198
Pena Blanca $928
Penasco $871
Pep $2,214
Peralta $1,020
Petaca $5,398
Picacho $1,105
Pie Town $906
Pinehill $959
Pinon $1,029
Placitas $835
Playas $967
Pojoaque $812
Polvadera $949
Ponderosa $821
Ponderosa Pine $871
Portales $2,823
Prewitt $789
Pueblo of Acoma $944
Quay $5,795
Quemado $845
Questa $922
Radium Springs $767
Rainsville $1,093
Ramah $824
Ranchos de Taos $873
Raton $2,231
Red River $888
Redrock $828
Regina $871
Rehoboth $852
Reserve $814
Ribera $1,173
Rincon $786
Rio Communities $1,004
Rio Rancho $791
Rociada $1,093
Rodeo $806
Rogers $2,848
Roswell $1,893
Rowe $949
Roy $2,692
Ruidoso $971
Ruidoso Downs $970
Sacramento $944
Saint Vrain $2,938
Salem $760
San Acacia $948
San Antonio $927
San Cristobal $902
San Felipe Pueblo $845
San Fidel $823
San Ildefonso Pueblo $813
San Jon $2,953
San Jose $1,056
San Miguel $779
San Patricio $976
San Rafael $5,459
San Ysidro $807
Sandia Heights $792
Sandia Knolls $841
Sandia Park $858
Sanostee $796
Santa Clara $797
Santa Clara Pueblo $891
Santa Cruz $877
Santa Fe $788
Santa Rosa $2,198
Santa Teresa $941
Santo Domingo Pueblo $922
Sapello $1,575
Sausal $999
Sedan $4,207
Sedillo $873
Serafina $1,048
Sheep Springs $963
Shiprock $782
Silver City $820
Skyline-Ganipa $944
Smith Lake $5,431
Socorro $908
Solano $3,009
South Valley $876
Spencerville $819
Springer $3,561
Stanley $866
Sunland Park $761
Sunspot $5,461
Taiban $2,862
Taos $889
Taos Pueblo $900
Taos Ski Valley $950
Tatum $3,110
Tererro $1,142
Tesuque $5,434
Texico $2,868
Thoreau $798
Tierra Amarilla $909
Tijeras $871
Timberon $909
Tinnie $1,057
Tohatchi $954
Tome $981
Torreon $987
Trampas $1,018
Trementina $1,677
Tres Piedras $1,018
Truchas $1,018
Truth or Consequences $817
Tucumcari $2,448
Tularosa $861
Twin Lakes $5,364
University Park $761
Upper Fruitland $790
Ute Park $5,454
Vadito $860
Vado $813
Valdez $857
Valencia $983
Vallecitos $934
Valmora $1,450
Vanderwagen $927
Veguita $1,007
Velarde $907
Wagon Mound $1,523
Waterflow $791
Watrous $1,450
Weed $946
West Hammond $860
White Rock $808
White Sands $844
White Sands Missile Range $879
Whites City $1,827
Willard $1,024
Williamsburg $790
Winston $860
Yah-ta-hey $5,362
Yeso $2,422
Youngsville $942
Zia Pueblo $836
Zuni Pueblo $925

Home and auto insurance bundling in New Mexico

How can you lower the rate of homeowners insurance in New Mexico? One way is by bundling your auto insurance and home insurance policies.

Average annual rate (without bundling) Average annual rate (with bundling) Yearly savings (in $) Yearly savings (in percent)
$1,716 $1,551 $165 9.62%

Home insurance discounts in New Mexico

Using the discounts provided by your insurer is another way by which you can lower the cost of New Mexico home insurance. But ensure to check which discounts you qualify for.

Insurer Bundling Discounts Loyalty Discounts Military Discounts New Home Credit Discounts Claim-Free Discounts Protective Devices Discounts
Farmers -
Allstate - -
State Farm - - -
USAA -
Nationwide - -
Liberty Mutual - - - - -
Progressive - - -
Amica - -
Chubb - -

Comparing common features across top companies

Are you trying to buy the best homeowners insurance in New Mexico? Then check whether your insurer offers these features.

Insurer Identity Theft Protection Valuable Possessions Water Backup Other Structures Coverage Dwelling /Personal Property Replacement
Farmers Optional No Optional Optional
Allstate Optional Optional Optional Optional
State Farm Optional Optional Optional Optional
USAA Optional No
Nationwide Optional Optional Optional Optional
Liberty Mutual Optional Optional Optional Optional
Progressive No Optional Optional
Amica Optional Optional Optional Optional
Chubb Optional Optional

Common causes of home insurance claims in New Mexico

These are a few reasons that lead to home insurance claims in the state.

  • Wildfires: Many New Mexico homes are susceptible to fire damage, especially during the drier months.
  • Earthquakes: Earthquakes don't often occur in New Mexico. But when they occur, strong quakes can cause substantial home damage.
  • Flooding: Flooding can occur after severe thunderstorms, causing structural and electrical damage to your home. A standard New Mexico homeowners insurance policy doesn't cover flooding;you must buy it separately.
  • Theft: It is another reason for more claims in the state.

Does homeowners insurance cover flooding in New Mexico?

No. Standard homeowners insurance doesn’t cover flood damage. So you must buy flood insurance via FEMA’s National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private insurer to protect your house against flood damage. The coverage from private flood insurers may differ; however, NFIP flood insurance offers the following coverage.

  • Your home's structure - $250,000
  • Personal property - $100,000

See what you could save on home insurance

Does home insurance cover damage caused by fires in New Mexico?

Every New Mexico home insurance policy includes fire coverage by default. If your home becomes damaged or destroyed by fire, your insurer will cover the damage up to the policy limits. A wildfire could cause damage to 14% of New Mexico homes. So it is a must to buy a home insurance policy.

Depending on your policy, you may need additional living expenses coverage if your home is deemed unlivable. Intentional damage (arson) or damage to an empty home are examples of fire-related damages that your insurer does not cover.

Factors that affect home insurance rates in New Mexico

Do you want to buy cheap homeowners insurance in New Mexico? Then check for these factors before buying one.

  • Your location: Factors like your ZIP Code, the volume of nearby claims, and the area's theft rate impact New Mexico home insurance rates.
  • Replacement cost: Home insurance costs in New Mexico differ depending on local labor and construction material rates.
  • Age/condition: Older properties are more expensive to insure than newer properties.
  • Claims history:If you frequently submit claims, insurers will consider you risky. Expect your insurance rates to surge then.
  • Credit history: Most insurers will verify your credit score before providing you with home insurance coverage. If you have a poor credit score, be prepared to spend big on New Mexico home insurance.
  • Dog breed: Many insurers label some dog breeds 'dangerous.' If your insurer considers your dog this way, the price of New Mexico home insurance will increase.

Tips for buying homeowners insurance

Are you looking to find the best homeowners insurance in New Mexico? Then follow these tips!

  • Assess your rebuilding costs: Consult an agent or a reputed builder to check how much it would cost to reconstruct your house with affordable building materials and local labor.
  • Review the advantage of replacement cost over actual cash value: Buying replacement cost insurance for your house and other possessions will be required.
  • Consider add-on coverage for your expensive items: If you own expensive items like musical instruments, high-end electronics, sporting gear, or old antiques, you'll need personal property coverage.
  • Evaluate your liability coverage needs: Determine your required minimum liability insurance.
  • Assess coverage gaps: Many insurers provide higher coverage limits for landscaping elements like trees and bushes.
  • Check financial ratings: Ratings from organizations like AM Best and Standard & Poor's may be there for most home insurers. For instance, some firms won't let you apply for a mortgage if your insurer doesn't have a minimum 'A' financial strength rating.
  • Check for discounts: Use all the discounts the insurer offers that you qualify for.
  • Compare quotes from various insurance companies: New Mexico home insurance premiums may differ depending on your chosen insurer. To find an ideal home insurance policy in New Mexico, compare quotes from all insurance companies if possible.

Most common disasters in New Mexico

Disasters by month

According to FEMA, New Mexico suffered the most declared disasters in March, May, and June.

Month Number of disasters
January 4
February 1
March 15
April 8
May 16
June 29
July 4
August 6
September 7
October 6
November 3
December 1

Disasters by month

According to FEMA, residents face an average of four declared disasters every year.

year Number of disasters
2001 1
2002 9
2003 2
2004 3
2005 1
2006 6
2007 3
2008 3
2009 1
2010 3
2011 10
2012 5
2013 5
2014 2
2015 0
2016 2
2017 2
2018 2
2019 1
2020 10

How to get New Mexico home insurance with Way.com

The average cost of homeowners insurance in New Mexico is $1,716 annually. However, you can even find a reasonable home insurance policy. But how can you get one? That’s where Way.com can help you!

You must use our app or website to obtain quotes from all insurers in the state. Then you must compare them and buy a policy with the most reasonable rate. Do you need additional help? Then our home insurance agents in the state can guide you. They will help you understand New Mexico home insurance laws, the most complex insurance terms, discounts, and coverages.

FAQs

What is the average cost of homeowners insurance in New Mexico?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in New Mexico is $1,716 yearly.

Does New Mexico require homeowners insurance?

Although the state does not require homeowners to purchase home insurance, many lenders do so that people can receive and keep a mortgage. For instance, suppose you stop paying your home insurance premiums. In that case, your mortgage company may choose an insurance company and charge you for it.

How much is homeowners insurance for Las Cruces, New Mexico?

It costs $796 annually.

Why is homeowners insurance so expensive in New Mexico?

Because of the state’s high wildfire risk and burglary rate, New Mexico has high home insurance rates.


Digital Insurance Card

Access your digital insurance card through the app. You no longer need to carry your physical insurance card with you.

Get reminders & quotes

Receive reminders before your renewal. Way.com will also send new quotes from up to 45 insurance companies with your renewal reminder.

Share with family

Keep everyone on your policy up to date by sharing your insurance information.

Manage your policy

Make changes to your policy right from the app (coming soon) and ask for expert advice.

Get the App:

Find the best home insurance rates on-the-go

For the best user experience, please download our Way app.

Please Enter A Valid Mobile Number!
Text Sent, Please download!

or

app store
google play