Get free quote in-app

(400K+)

Our Insurance Partners

nationwide
travellers
mapfre
safeco
kemper
national-general
foremost
dairyland
pronto
bristolwest
hippo
assuranceameric
anchor
still-water
bridger
alinsco
commonwealth
suncoast
aspire

Introduction

When you're in a car accident with another motorist, your car insurance coverage can assist you from the financial consequences. Insurance claims, on the other hand, are handled differently based on your state's fault laws.

Your personal injury protection (PIP) insurance covers your own medical fees in a no-fault state, whereas the at-fault driver's bodily injury liability coverage covers the other driver's hospital bills in an at-fault state. If you are involved in an accident, knowing how claims are settled in your state may help you feel more at ease with the claim's procedure.

At Fault v/s No Fault Accidents Key Differences

At-Fault Accidents No-Fault Accidents
A driver who causes a car accident in an at-fault accident, commonly known as a tort state, is accountable for compensating the opposing party or parties for their losses. A crash that occurs in a state with no-fault laws is known as a no-fault accident.
These accidents can be covered through an insurance claim or by the at-fault driver paying the other party with his or her own money. In a no-fault state, regardless of who caused the collision, both drivers' insurance companies will pay for their medical expenses using their PIP coverage.

Accidents in At-Fault States

A driver who causes an automobile accident in an at-fault state, often known as a tort state, is accountable for compensating the opposing party or parties for their losses. This can be done through an insurance claim or by the at-fault driver personally paying the other party.

If you cause a collision and utilize your insurance to cover the costs, the property damage liability section of your policy will cover the other driver's car damages, while bodily injury liability insurance will cover the other driver's and passengers' medical expenditures if they are hurt. This coverage will only pay up to your policy's limitations, and any excess will be your liability to cover out of pocket.

Your insurance policy may also pay for damage to your automobile, as well as your injuries and the injuries of your passengers, depending on the coverage you have.

See what you could save on auto insurance

How much does insurance go up after an At-Fault Accident by Insurer

State Average Insurance rate after an at-fault accident with property damage Average insurance rate increases after at-fault accidents with injuries
Alabama 50% 49%
Alaska 52% 56%
Arizona 53% 54%
Arkansas 53% 54%
California 78% 103%
Colorado 41% 39%
Connecticut 57% 58%
Delaware 40% 40%
Florida 44% 45%
Georgia 53% 53%
Hawaii 43% 43%
Idaho 43% 43%
Illinois 55% 55%
Indiana 54% 54%
Iowa 51% 53%
Kansas 47% 47%
Kentucky 59% 59%
Louisiana 54% 54%
Maine 46% 47%
Maryland 58% 58%
Massachusetts 73% 73%
Michigan 51% 51%
Minnesota 47% 48%
Mississipi 52% 53%
Missouri 42% 43%
Montana 47% 47%
Nebraska 54% 54%
Nevada 40% 50%
New Hampshire 61% 61%
New Jersey 48% 49%
New Mexico 43% 43%
New York 46% 46%
North Carolina 85% 96%
North Dakota 45% 45%
Ohio 51% 51%
Oklahoma 50% 51%
Oregon 48% 49%
Pennysylvania 61% 51%
Rhode Island 45% 45%
South Dakota 48% 48%
South Carolina 45% 45%
Tennessee 50% 51%
Texas 60% 60%
Utah 50% 50%
Vermont 53% 53%
Virginia 51% 51%
Washington 42% 43%
West Virginia 47% 47%
Wisconsin 56% 56%
Wyoming 37% 37%

Tips for Lowering Car Insurance after an At-Fault Accident

  • Inform Your Car Insurance Provider of Your Accident.
  • Inquire with your auto insurance company about accident forgiveness.
  • Look for a car insurance company that charges a lower premium.
  • Enhance your credit rating.
  • Investigate Insurance Savings.
  • If you don't need comprehensive coverage, consider dropping it.
  • Enroll in a car insurance program that is based on how much you drive.

Accidents in No Fault States

No-fault states, contrary to their name, nonetheless have fault. No-fault insurance only covers injuries sustained in collisions; drivers are still responsible for any property damage they cause if they collide with another car.

In a no-fault state, regardless of who caused the collision, both drivers' insurance companies will pay for their medical expenses using their PIP coverage. However, employing property damage liability coverage, the at-fault motorist is usually compelled to compensate the other driver for their automobile repairs.

Who pays in a No-Fault Accident

If two drivers are involved in an accident, each party's PIP coverage normally compensates for their respective medical bills and/or lost wages up to the limits of their policies, regardless of who caused the accident.

No-fault states, on the other hand, may allow injured drivers to sue the at-fault driver if certain circumstances are met. Furthermore, much like in an at-fault state, the at-fault driver's insurance usually compensates for damage to the other driver's car and property. This is why even in no-fault states, drivers must have liability insurance.

Making a No-Fault Accident Claim

If you have no-fault insurance and are involved in an accident, you should call your insurance company right away to file a claim. When speaking with your insurance agent, be open and honest, and submit all documents as soon as possible.

Remember that no-fault insurance only covers bodily injuries sustained as a consequence of an accident. If your vehicle is damaged in an accident in a no-fault state, the at-fault driver's property damage liability insurance will be responsible for paying for your vehicle damages.

What damage does No-Fault Car Insurance Cover?

You can usually seek compensation for a number of economic or out-of-pocket damages resulting from a car accident if you file a no-fault insurance or PIP claim, including:

  • Medical expenses incurred as a result of your automobile accident injuries.
  • Earnings lost as a result of your injuries (up to a specific limit).
  • Expenditures of replacement services (for example, duties you can't do because of your injuries) and burial/funeral costs if someone died as a result of the accident.
  • One of the most important aspects of the no-fault system is that you cannot receive compensation for pain and suffering as part of your claim.

Is No-Fault Car Insurance Optional?

In 18 states, no-fault insurance is compulsory. Importantly, some states require medical payments insurance (or med pay) to cover medical bills incurred in an accident, rather than no-fault insurance.

How does payment work when both sides are at-fault in an accident?

Depending on the regulations in each state, the insurers on both sides may find that the accident was caused by a shared fault. If both parties are found to be at blame for an accident, the number of damages paid to each party for injury or property responsibility claims will be determined by the state's negligence statute.

Add-on coverage

Drivers in states with an add-on insurance system can sue the at-fault party (just as they can in fault-based insurance systems), but they can also add first-party coverage if they prefer their own insurance company to cover certain expenses.

PIP

In the insurance world, no-fault car insurance is known as "personal injury protection" or "PIP" coverage. In so-called "no-fault" jurisdictions, PIP is compulsory, but it can be added to any car insurance coverage in any state. It doesn't matter who caused your car accident when filing a claim under PIP coverage, whether it's mandated or optional in your state.

Accident Forgiveness

Accident forgiveness is a sort of vehicle insurance coverage that guarantees that your premiums will not rise after your first at-fault collision. It's sometimes included as standard in car insurance policies, but most of the time it's marketed as an endorsement or add-on coverage. If you get into an accident, accident forgiveness can save you a lot of money, but not every collision is covered. Car insurance providers will frequently only waive the first accident on your coverage.

See what you could save on auto insurance

Insurance providers with accident forgiveness program

Below given are some of the best insurance providers with accident forgiveness programs

Not-at-fault accidents

A crash that occurs in a state with no-fault laws is known as a no-fault accident. When you are not the cause of an accident, such as when someone rear-ends you, it is known as a not-at-fault accident.

Types of Negligence

In the world of car insurance, negligence denotes fault. You are at fault if you are negligent in an automobile accident. Pure contributory, pure comparative, and modified comparative negligence are the three categories of negligence. Even if you have a PIP policy, you may be unable to file a claim under the other driver's BI insurance. Because each state defines negligence differently, this process varies by state.

Pure contributory

When a motorist is found to be fully blameless in a car accident, the insurance company will only reimburse them. You won't be eligible for an insurance settlement if the other motorist can show you played even a minor role in the collision. This sort of carelessness is practised in only four states and the District of Columbia.

Pure comparative

A driver's compensation is based on a percentage of fault in this form of negligence. This sort of negligence is used in twelve states, three of which are "no-fault" states. Determining the exact degree of fault is an evident danger of this form of negligence.

Modified comparative

This sort of carelessness includes the proportion of a driver's fault as well, but it establishes a threshold, which is normally 50% or 51% depending on the jurisdiction. The modified pure comparative negligence model is used in more than 30 jurisdictions. South Dakota uses a similar "slight/gross negligence" method that does not employ percentages. Instead, an at-fault driver is only eligible for compensation if they are "somewhat negligent."

How is Fault determined in a car crash?

With only anecdotal evidence, proving fault can be challenging. However, it can mean the difference between receiving a payout and receiving nothing, as well as affecting future auto insurance rates. Insurers often raise your auto insurance rates when a driver is at least 50% at fault in a car collision.

Certain resources can be used to prove your innocence or the other driver's responsibility.

Police reports

When officers are dispatched to an accident scene, they prepare and file an official report. It includes an objective assessment of the incident, as well as an assessment of who was at blame and whether or not drugs or alcohol were involved.

State laws

Knowing your state's traffic regulations might help you determine if the other party in the collision has some fault. Consult your state's motor vehicle website, your local DMV, or the public library in your area.

Many driving laws appear to be easy, yet they are actually complex. If your car hits a cyclist, for example, it may appear that you are entirely to blame. Bicyclists, on the other hand, may be required by traffic laws to stay in a certain area of the road.

Auto Insurance Data Methodology

The auto insurance rates published in this guide are based on the results of research completed by Way.com’s data team. Using a mix of public and internal data, we analyzed millions of rate averages across U.S. ZIP codes.

Quotes are typically based on a full coverage policy average unless otherwise noted within the content.

These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes will differ. Given this, it’s important to go through our insurance steps form to find how much you can save with way.com

FAQs

What is the difference between at-fault and no-fault accidents?

When an accident happens in most states, one party is usually considered "at-fault" and is responsible for the injuries sustained by the other driver and their passengers. Medical expenditures are covered by each driver's personal injury protection (PIP) coverage rather than the at-fault driver's insurance in some jurisdictions known as "no-fault" states.

Do insurance rates go up after no-fault accidents?

Car accidents aren't always "chargeable." Here are some examples of accidents that are not chargeable:

  • When your car was damaged, it was legally parked.
  • Your car was rear-ended by another vehicle, but you (or the driver of your car) were not charged with any moving traffic violations as a result of the collision.
  • A hit-and-run driver collided with your vehicle. (Depending on your state and insurance coverage, you may be obligated to report the collision to the police within 24 hours of discovering the damage.)
  • The driver of another vehicle was found guilty of a moving traffic offence in connection with the accident, but you were not found guilty.
  • A collision with an animal or fowl caused the accident.
  • Falling items, flying gravel, and missile-like things caused the damage.
  • If you are a volunteer or paid member of a fire department, first aid team, or police enforcement organization, the accident occurred while you were responding to an emergency.
  • Subrogation (usually, this implies they were able to collect from the other driver's car insurance company) allowed your car insurance company to recover 80 percent or more of your collision insurance claim.
  • The individual who caused the damage compensated you.
  • For the accident, there is a court judgement against the person who caused the damage.
  • Accidents in which claim payments are made under the personal injury protection (PIP) policy but no payments are made under the liability or collision insurance policies.

What happens after no-fault accidents?

Even in a no-fault state, culpability is still allocated when an accident happens. The main distinction is who is responsible for medical expenses. PIP coverage (in addition to standard liability insurance) is required in no-fault states, and it pays for medical expenses and lost earnings regardless of who caused the accident. On the flip, PIP insurance raises the cost of auto insurance dramatically, which is one of the reasons why insurance in no-fault jurisdictions is often higher than in tort states.

Does full coverage cover no-fault accidents?

If you have full coverage automobile insurance, your vehicle is protected for both collision and non-collision damage, regardless of who is at fault.

Is Texas a no-fault state for car accidents?

Some states have "no-fault" rules in effect when it comes to car accidents and insurance legislation, while others have "at-fault" laws. When it comes to car accidents, Texas is an at-fault state; specifically, it is a "comparative blame" jurisdiction.

What is a no-fault state for car accidents?

The driver who caused the damage to your car must nonetheless pay for repairs or replacement in a no-fault state. Because the state's no-fault statutes only apply to injury claims, not property damage, this is the case.

How long do at-fault accidents stay on record?

At-fault accidents have stayed on record for about three years. Your accident history is used by insurance providers to help calculate the cost of your policy. A significant at-fault accident on your record, or numerous at-fault accidents, will almost certainly result in a premium hike for a few years.

Learn more by city and state for car insurance



Learn more by city and state for car insurance




Digital Insurance Card

Access your digital insurance card through the app. You no longer need to carry your physical insurance card with you.

Get reminders & quotes

Receive reminders before your renewal. Way.com will also send new quotes from up to 45 insurance companies with your renewal reminder.

Share with family

Keep everyone on your policy up to date by sharing your insurance information.

Manage your policy

Make changes to your policy right from the app (coming soon) and ask for expert advice.

Get the App:

Find the best Auto insurance rates on-the-go

For the best user experience, please download our Way app.

Please Enter A Valid Mobile Number!
Text Sent, Please download!

or